Revolving Doors 101: Specifying a more energy-efficient, secure opening

May 1, 2012

All images courtesy Horton Automatics[1]
All images courtesy Horton Automatics

By Bob Augustine and Elias Campos
Revolving doors have been manufactured for over a century. Theophilus Van Kannel was granted U.S. patent 387,571 on August 7, 1888 for a “Storm-door Structure” that was a three-partition revolving door. Since then, their general benefits have remained the same—creating comfort, saving energy, improving traffic flow, and enhancing security. The design of these doors eliminates drafts and keeps debris from entering the building.

A revolving door is essentially a freestanding vestibule. What makes these doors unique is they are always open and receptive to pedestrians, but simultaneously always closed to the outside elements. This second point means less escape of the building’s conditioned air or penetration by the exterior. Empirical studies (discussed later in this article) demonstrate revolving doors are approximately eight times more energy-efficient than slide- or swing-door systems.

They are viewed as a cold-climate solution, but heightened awareness of the need to conserve energy has increased their use in warmer regions—it is just as important to keep air-conditioning in the building. Over the past two decades, revolving doors have also been sold to meet security requirements in both Fortune 500 companies and airports.

Configurations and safety considerations
Typically, revolving doors are made up of the components illustrated in Figure 1. The products generally come in four, three, and two-wing configurations; each offers advantages the architect typically matches to the building use and design. Additionally, the specifier has the ability to select either a segmented or round drum. Various benefits to the designs are listed in Figure 2.

For both Canada and the United States, revolving doors are designed, manufactured, and installed per American National Standards Institute (ANSI) A156.27, Power and Manual Operated Revolving Pedestrian Doors. For manual systems, the primary safety control is to limit the rotating speed with canopy- or floor-mounted controls. The maximum allowable speed is 12 rotations per minute (rpm).

Revolving door terminology.[2]Automatic revolving doors are furnished with a series of active and passive sensors. These are similar to those for the automatic swinging and sliding doors. For wing safety, ANSI A156.27 Section 16.1 requires the sensors to detect a 711-mm (28-in.) tall person in the rotating path a minimum of 254 mm (10 in.) from the wing (Figure 3).

Automatic revolving doors also require entry-point sensors to prevent entrapment at the intersection of the rotating wing and the approaching drum wall. The ANSI standard calls for these sensors to detect the presence of a person or object when the door wing approaches, and stop the rotation (Figure 4).

Number of wings and drum construction options.[3]In addition to the wall sensor, the drum edge farthest from the rotating wing is furnished with a contact safety edge. This edge, according to ANSI A156.27 Section 17.1, is required to detect any 44.5 N (10-lbf) obstruction (or greater) and immediately stop the door rotation. This redundant protection ensures enhanced safety to pedestrians and peace of mind to business owners and overall traffic (Figure 5).

The bottom rail of the wing is typically furnished with a ‘toe-guard’ sensor. Under ANSI A156.27 Section 17.2, sensors are designed to detect an obstruction no more than 1.2 m (4 ft) from the floor and with less than 44.5 N of pressure, and then stop the door rotation. It is intended to eliminate the possibility of a person’s heel being trapped under the wing (Figure 6).

Further, Section 20.1 of ANSI A156.27 requires the furnishing of emergency buttons. These are designed to remove the power of an automatic door; they must be located on both sides of the door and stop its rotation until reset (Figure 7).

Revolving doors connect to the surrounding infrastructure either at the ‘throat’ or at the centre (Figure 8). The selection is typically dictated by design. For example, an option to consider is whether it is possible to have a portion of the revolving door on the sidewalk. A cropped canopy gives the flexibility to install a revolving door flush with the storefront. With the door being throat-connected, the revolving door stays inside the building. This design could reduce interference with pedestrian traffic using the sidewalks. For most standalone buildings, the centre-connected option is the norm.

The active wing sensor pattern is shaded in red.[4]
The active wing sensor pattern is shaded in red.
Active entry point sensor.[5]
Active entry point sensor.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Specifying the right product
Critical to all designs and applications is an understanding of the particular building’s use and traffic patterns. There are four main possibilities:

Manual doors
Typical applications for manual revolving doors include:

These openings can accommodate large volumes of traffic in both directions. The choice between a three- or four-wing design depends on the application and the people using the entrance. The latter option provides a slightly larger throughput as four people in each direction can pass through the door with each revolution; additionally, the throat opening is larger. Consequently, it is recommended on higher-volume applications where capacity is a concern such as a conference centre or university.

Safety edge passive sensor.[6]
Safety edge passive sensor.
Bottom rail passive sensor.[7]
Bottom rail passive sensor.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A three-wing design is preferable in a hotel application where the larger compartment size is more critical. Guests at a hotel typically have rolling or carried luggage and the larger compartment size is more suitable. Some grocery stores and restaurants use three-wing doors to accommodate a parent with a child conveniently in the same compartment. Most manual doors are supplied in diameter sizes of 1.9, 2.1, or 2.4 m (6 ½, 7, or 8 ft).

Automatic doors
With the need for hands-free operation, the typical applications for automatic revolving doors include airports, hotels, casinos, and hospitals. These doors can accommodate larger items like golf clubs and skis, but they are also used in healthcare applications as they can deal with wheelchairs and those walking with assistance.

Automatic revolving doors are installed when one needs to conveniently move larger volumes of people through a front entrance while maintaining high energy efficiency standards. Choices in automatic revolving doors are two-, three-, and four-wing; they are typically 3 m (10 ft) in diameter and larger.

Emergency buttons.[8]
Emergency buttons.
The centre-connected setup.[9]
The centre-connected setup.

The two-wing design offers the largest compartment size and the best airlock. In a hospital application, this assembly can accommodate gurneys. It offers the largest compartment size as there is no centre shaft or core. The entire door, including the ceiling, rotates on a channel installed in the canopy.

It offers the best airlock because in lieu of a single, centre core there are two—one on each of the wings. These cores completely close the throat opening to outside elements and are desirable in cold climates to prevent ice and snow from entering the throat opening during non-operating hours. When the wings completely close the throat opening, this is the only revolving door that is not ‘always open and always closed’ during part of its rotation.

Due to the increased mechanical components necessary for this configuration, including the rotating ceiling, the two-wing is typically more costly than comparable three- or four-wing alternatives.

Airport exit lanes.[10]
Airport exit lanes.

The most common automatic revolving door is a three-wing design; this style offers convenience and energy efficiency while maintaining a lower cost to install. Since it has a larger compartment size than the four-wing, one can move large volumes of people through. A 3-m diameter revolving door in a three-wing design allows an unassisted wheelchair to pass through the door. (An assisted wheelchair requires a diameter of 3.7 m [12 ft].) The standard sizes of both two- and three-wing doors are from 3 to 4.9 m (10 to 16 ft) in diameter.

The four-wing design is very seldom used in an automatic configuration, as the compartment sizes become small. The required wing sensors take up too much of the usable compartment size, causing the door to stop or slow too frequently in a two-way traffic situation. As a result, several manufacturers have discontinued offering this product, especially with viable options in two- and three-wing designs.

Security doors
Revolving doors have been used to provide a secure entrance for more than 20 years. When a swing or slide door is equipped with a card reader and the necessary magnetic lock or electric strike, it is assumed to be a secure entrance. The deficiency with this philosophy, however, is once the door is open there is nothing to prevent multiple people from entering with the authorized person and breaching the intended security. A two-way security revolving door will address risk scenarios like tailgating (i.e. unauthorized entry attempt while an authorized person is entering or exiting) and piggybacking (i.e. unauthorized entry [forcible or collusion] in the same compartment with an authorized person).

A revolving security door turns one compartment at a time, allowing only a single person to enter the secure area. A four-wing design is ideal to provide two-way control. Security revolving doors have also been specified for dormitory and office building applications where they function as standard openings by day, and security areas by night.

Light curtain.[11]
Light curtain.

Airport exit lane turnstiles
All airports have secure and non-secure sides (sometimes called ‘airside’ and ‘landside’). Exit lane turnstiles keep these two areas separated. Entering through security has become routine for experienced travellers. People are required to place many of their personal belongings on a conveyor belt and pass through the metal detectors. After arriving at the destination, they pass by a security guard and leave the airport through a barrier-free walkway.

For the past 15 to 20 years, many airports have installed a physical barrier that takes the passengers and employees from the secure side back to the non-secure side through a one-way security revolving door. Typically supplied in a three-wing design, this door allows passengers to leave the airport through a secure one-way exit. It can eliminate the need for a security guard to be stationed at this door, and enable the guard to be deployed to make roving patrols (Figure 9).

In the past five to seven years, some airport authorities have requested an additional level of security to prevent objects from being thrown or placed into the revolving door and ‘pushed’ through to the secured side. Light curtains and volumetric sensors prevent anyone from having an object swept into the secure side. They are installed in the same secure quadrant (Figure 10).

Efficiency and savings
Empirical studies by Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air-conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) have demonstrated revolving doors to be a significant source of energy savings.1 Therefore, they can also be contributors toward points under Canada Green Building Council’s (CaGBC’s) Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) program.  (In terms of LEED, possible credits to which revolving doors can contribute include Energy and Atmosphere (EA) Credit 1, Optimizing Energy Performance, Materials and Resources (MR) Credit 4, Recycled Content, Indoor Environmental Quality (EQ) Credit 4.2, Low-emitting Materials, and EQ Credit 6.2, Controllability of Systems: Thermal Comfort).

The study concluded the amount of energy to cool or warm a building is directly related to the amount of air exchanged to/from the building. Since revolving doors keep a better airlock than traditional swing or sliding doors, it follows the energy needs to keep the building at a preset temperature is lower than using a traditional entrance.

Naturally, in determining the savings, there are several factors involved. They include:

Figure 11 illustrates the example of a 18-m (60-ft) tall Toronto building equipped with a three-wing, 3-m (10-ft)
revolving door instead of a vestibule entrance with two 2.8-m (9 1/5-ft) sliders.
According to one analysis, the results would be:

Toronto revolver energy savings simulation results.[12]
Toronto revolver energy savings simulation results.

Conclusion
Beyond security, energy efficiency, and traffic performance, one must also consider the esthetic impact of a revolving door. Will it give the intended look of a building’s entrance and will it architecturally meet one’s needs?

Major airports, hotels, hospitals, and casinos have all chosen revolving doors for an ‘enhanced’ appearance. While enjoying the energy-efficient benefits previously discussed, revolving doors meet high architectural demand and appeal. The finish can be furnished to match adjacent construction and the wing/drum design can match important sight lines. Although revolving doors have been around for more than a century, it is quite likely that the next 10 years will bring about major increase in demand and acceptance as a preferred entrance solution.

Bob Augustine is the vice-president of sales for Horton Automatics. A 20-year veteran of the industry, he manages the company’s architectural development programs and works with distributors throughout the Americas. Augustine can be reached at bob_augustine@overheaddoor.com.

Elias Campos is Horton’s vice-president of marketing and product development. He has extensive experience in infrastructure project management, marketing, and sales. Campos’ experience includes stints with PDVSA-Citgo, Emerson Electric, and Overhead Door Corp. He can be contacted via e-mail at elias_campos@overheaddoor.com[13].

Endnotes:
  1. [Image]: http://www.constructioncanada.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/GrandCondell116.jpg
  2. [Image]: http://www.constructioncanada.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/1-Figure.jpg
  3. [Image]: http://www.constructioncanada.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/2-Figure.jpg
  4. [Image]: http://www.constructioncanada.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/3-Figure.jpg
  5. [Image]: http://www.constructioncanada.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/4-Figure.jpg
  6. [Image]: http://www.constructioncanada.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/5-Figure.jpg
  7. [Image]: http://www.constructioncanada.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/6-Figure.jpg
  8. [Image]: http://www.constructioncanada.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/7-Figure.jpg
  9. [Image]: http://www.constructioncanada.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/8-Figure.jpg
  10. [Image]: http://www.constructioncanada.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/9-Figure.jpg
  11. [Image]: http://www.constructioncanada.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/10-Figure.jpg
  12. [Image]: http://www.constructioncanada.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/11-Figure.jpg
  13. elias_campos@overheaddoor.com: mailto:elias_campos@overheaddoor.com

Source URL: https://www.constructioncanada.net/revolving-doors-101-specifying-a-more-energy-efficient-secure-opening/